How often should you replace your mascara?
At BeautyCaters, our expert team independently curates every recommended product. Purchases through our links may earn us a commission. Explore our transparent selection process.
“When was the last time you actually replaced your mascara?”
A frequently overlooked aspect of mascara hygiene is its replacement schedule. Experts in ophthalmology and cosmetic science advise adherence to specific timelines to mitigate eye health risks and preserve product integrity. This article addresses the pivotal question, ‘How often should you replace your mascara?‘ and elucidates the factors influencing its shelf life and the implications for eye health.

Why do you need to change your mascara every few months?
Every time you withdraw and reinsert your mascara wand, you’re unwittingly introducing a cocktail of microorganisms from your eyelashes into the tube. This creates an ideal environment for bacterial proliferation: warm, dark, and moist. The proteins and sugars in the mascara formula serve as a nutrient-rich medium for these microbes to thrive. Over time, the bacterial load can escalate dramatically, transforming your mascara into a potential source of infection.
This isn’t merely a matter of aesthetic concern; it’s a genuine health risk. The delicate ocular environment is particularly vulnerable to microbial invasion. The consequences of using contaminated mascara can range from mild discomfort to severe infections.
Also Read: Can you use mascara on eyebrows?
What are the risks of using old mascara?
Mascara, by its very nature, is susceptible to bacterial contamination. Each time the wand is used, microorganisms from your eyelashes and skin are transferred into the tube. This creates a perfect environment for bacteria like Staphylococcus epidermidis to thrive. While these bacteria are naturally present on your skin, excessive buildup can trigger adverse reactions, especially in the sensitive eye area.
- Conjunctivitis (Pink Eye): This highly contagious inflammation of the conjunctiva, the transparent membrane covering the sclera and lining the eyelids, can result in redness, itching, discharge, and a gritty sensation.
- Blepharitis: Inflammation of the eyelid margins, often caused by bacterial overgrowth, can lead to chronic redness, irritation, crusting, and even eyelash loss.
- Styes and chalazions: Infected oil glands in the eyelids can manifest as painful styes (external) or chalazions (internal), requiring medical intervention in severe cases.
- Corneal infections: In rare but serious instances, contaminated mascara can lead to corneal infections, potentially threatening vision.
- Allergic reactions: Besides infections, the accumulation of bacteria and degraded ingredients can trigger allergic reactions, causing redness, itching, and swelling.
How often should you replace your mascara?
The consensus among dermatologists and makeup experts is that mascara should be replaced every three months. This time frame is not arbitrary; it’s based on the understanding that mascara’s liquid or semi-liquid formulation, coupled with repeated wand insertion, creates an ideal breeding ground for bacteria.
When you need a new mascara?
While, three months is a general rule, certain signs indicate the need for earlier replacement:
- Changes in texture: If your mascara becomes clumpy, thick, or dry, it’s time to discard it.
- Unusual odor: A foul or chemical smell suggests bacterial contamination or product degradation.
- Flaking: If your mascara flakes off during application or throughout the day, it’s likely past its prime.
- Irritation: Any eye irritation, redness, or discomfort after mascara use warrants immediate discontinuation and replacement.
How to make your mascara last?
While frequent mascara replacement is crucial, several strategies can help minimize bacterial buildup, maintain product quality, and get the most out of your mascara within its safe usage window. Proper storage, application techniques, and hygiene habits are key to extending mascara’s life without compromising eye health.
- Store your mascara upright to prevent air from entering the tube, which can cause drying and bacterial growth.
- Avoid storing mascara in areas with excessive heat and moisture, such as bathrooms. Instead, choose a cool, dark location like a drawer or makeup organizer.
- Contrary to a common myth, refrigerating mascara can actually increase bacterial production. The temperature fluctuations can create condensation, providing a moist environment for bacteria to thrive.
- Instead of pumping the wand in and out of the tube, which forces air inside and dries out the formula, gently twist the brush inside the tube to coat it evenly.
- Wipe off excess mascara from the brush after each use to prevent clumping and reduce bacterial transfer.
Sharing mascara is a major no-no, as it significantly increases the risk of spreading bacteria and infections.
- Use a marker to write the purchase date on your mascara tube. This helps you track its lifespan and know when it’s time to replace it.
- Adding water or saline to revive dry mascara introduces bacteria and alters the formula, making it unsafe for use.
- Always ensure the mascara tube is tightly closed after use to prevent air exposure and drying.

Prioritizing eye safety when using cosmetics is crucial, and the FDA provides excellent guidelines to help you do just that. Here’s a breakdown of essential tips to keep your eyes healthy and beautiful.
10 eye-makeup tips for halthy eyes
Your eyes are delicate, and any irritation should be taken seriously. Stop using any eye product immediately if it causes irritation. If the irritation doesn’t go away, it’s vital to consult a healthcare provider promptly. but to prevent eye health here are the following tips:
- Always wash your hands thoroughly before touching your eye cosmetics or applying them. This simple step prevents bacteria from your hands from contaminating your products and potentially causing an eye infection.
- Ensure that any cosmetic tool you use near your eyes, such as brushes or applicators, is spotlessly clean. Regular cleaning of these tools is just as important as handwashing.
- Protect your cosmetics from dust, dirt, and soil. If you notice any visible dust or dirt on the container, wipe it clean with a damp cloth.
- Don’t hold onto old containers. If you haven’t used a product for several months, it’s generally safer to dispose of it and purchase a new one. Preservatives can break down over time, making older products more susceptible to bacterial growth.
- Never spit into eye cosmetics. The bacteria present in your mouth can easily transfer to the product, multiply, and lead to an eye infection when you use it later.
- Avoid sharing your cosmetics. Sharing products means sharing bacteria, and another person’s bacteria could be harmful to your eyes. Be especially cautious with “testers” in retail stores; only use them if you’re certain they’ve been used with single-use applicators to prevent cross-contamination.
- Don’t store eye cosmetics at temperatures above 85°F (29°C). High temperatures, like those in a hot car, can weaken the preservatives in the product, increasing the risk of bacterial growth and infection.
- Refrain from using eye cosmetics if you have an eye infection or if the skin around your eye is red. Wait until the area has completely healed before resuming use.
- If you have any allergies, be extra careful when choosing and using eye cosmetics. Opt for hypoallergenic formulas if necessary and patch test new products.
Safe Application Practices
- When applying or removing eye cosmetics, be extremely careful not to scratch your eye. A sharp applicator or even a fingernail can cause damage.
- Never apply eye makeup while in a moving car or bus. Sudden stops or bumps can lead to injury to your eye if you’re holding an applicator near it.
- Avoid using glitter, metallic, or sparkle makeup on your eyes. These products can shed flakes that may fall into your eye, causing irritation or even infection.
- If you’re considering eyelash extensions, always have them applied by a qualified professional in a sanitary setting. This means an experienced aesthetician who uses chemicals that are safe for your skin and adheres to strict hygiene protocols.
By following these straightforward yet crucial tips from the FDA, you can significantly reduce the risk of eye infections and irritation, ensuring your eye cosmetic routine is both beautiful and safe.
Final word
Ultimately, timely mascara replacement is a non-negotiable aspect of responsible makeup usage. Following professional recommendations and paying attention to product changes will protect your eyes and ensure your mascara performs at its best. Make it a habit to regularly check and update your mascara, and enjoy the confidence that comes with healthy, beautiful eyes.