Written by: Divya

12 Best Waterproof Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes

At BeautyCaters, our expert team independently curates every recommended product. Purchases through our links may earn us a commission. Explore our transparent selection process.

Our eyes are windows to our soul, and this window reflects our inner purity and beauty. That’s why we always focus on beautifying the eyes, even when we adore a no-makeup look.

The BFF of a beautiful eye is eyeliner- we can’t even imagine a day without it. But, for sensitive eyes, this BFF turns into a foe in no time; if it is improper. What’s the solution?

Don’t let this friendship turn into enmity- and who can help? A sensitive eyeliner. They are available in plenty.

I researched and enlisted the 12 best waterproof eyeliner for sensitive eyes so that you could have beautiful, eye-conic eyes.

Top Pick
Physicians Formula Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio for sensitive eyes

Physicians Formula Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio

Best user experience.
Reasonable price.

best waterproof eyeliner for sensitive eyes

Best hypoallergenic eyeliners for sensitive eyes

Here are the 12 best waterproof eyeliners for sensitive allergic eyes and all of them are hypoallergenic:

1. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner (Bestseller)

The X-factor:– Well-defined eyes are just a twist away- twist the eyeliner to define them.

If you are tired of the dip and sketch technique, this eyeliner is a go-to solution; in one go and with one twist, you can draw irritation-free smooth, deep lines. And you don’t have to wait for it to dry up.

Review in detail:– This retractable eyeliner holds a creamy, rich weightless formula that glides effortlessly and stays for hours in hot and humid weather. When you wipe the face, it hardly smudges or gets transferred to the wipe. It is a vegan formulation; hence you won’t have to face irritation or discomfort wearing it on your sensitive eyes.


  • Need no sharpening.
  • Come in colorful shades.
  • Hypoallergenic eyeliner pencil.
  • Certified cruelty-free by PETA.
  • Value for money.


  • The soft kohl may break off.
  • Not too long-lasting.
NYX professional makeup mechanical eyeliner review
NYX professional makeup mechanical eyeliner for sensitive eyes

2. Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner (Trendy)

The X factor:– A liquid eyeliner, which goes through no skip, slip, or struggle.

Hold this liquid eyeliner and draw over your waterline the thin, thick, or winged lines without any struggle, slip, skip, and gaps to refill; because it is a liquid pen eyeliner, the trending version.

Review in detail:– The pen eyeliner has the revolutionary hyper-easy flexy-tip brush that easily fits in the waterline and delivers the smoothest glide. The hexagonal offers a comfortable and controlled grip. The intense formula takes only 20 seconds to dry and leaves a deep, dark color for the day without any budge, smudge, or discomfort.


  • Dark, satin finish.
  • 24-hour stay.
  • Ophthalmological tested.
  • Suit sensitive eyes and contact lenses.
  • Value for money.


  • Available in 2 shades.
  • Finish quickly.
Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner for sensitive eyes in America
Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner Review

Also read :

3. Physicians Formula Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio (Editor’s Choice)

The X-factor:Eyeliner that focuses on skin’s condition and needs.

Being from a brand designed for sensitive skin: the trio eyeliner defines your eyes and, at the same time, focuses on the condition and need of your skin and eyes. So, there is no chance of any discomfort.

Review in detail:– The hypoallergenic eyeliner pencils create a high-pigmented glamorous look irresistibly attractive. It could be natural, playful, and dramatic according to the occasion. The trio series is a collection of pencils with soft, thin tips that draw sharp and clear lines; swiftly. Neither does it feel heavy nor does it smudge and enter the eyes.


  • 24-hour stay formula.
  • A set of three colors.
  • Clinically-tested hypoallergenic.
  • Cruelty-free.
  • Value for money.


  • The nude shade is too light to show up.
  • Sharpener not included.
Physicians Formula Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio for sensitive eyes
Physicians Formula Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio

4. Vasanti Eyeliner Pencil (hygienic design)

The X-factor:- An eyeliner that embraces you with love!

A vegan formula, approved by medical practitioners, sits comfortably on the sensitive regions to create a natural, sultry look, eliminating the fear of having well-defined sensitive eyes – this is the Vasanti eyeliner pencil.

Review in detail:– This eyeliner for sensitive eyes is a creamy, smudge-proof formula that glides and creates a velvety matte finish even on the wet rims of the eyes. The eyes look big and bright and weightless. It is a non-retractable eyeliner pencil that twists up one way for hygienic application. It reduces the risk of harming or contaminating the eyes.


  • A comforting, rich-pigmented, long-wear formula.
  • Tested and approved by ophthalmologists and dermatologists.
  • Available in colorful shades.
  • Free from paraben and gluten.
  • Never tested on animals.


  • High-priced.
  • Need a careful twist.
Vasanti Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil for sensitive eyes
Vasanti Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil Review

5. Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner (EWG certified)

The X-factor:- An eyeliner free from over 3,500 harmful elements, even carbon black.

Staying true to its name: this hypoallergenic liquid eyeliner creates a no-fuss definition with a skin-friendly formula that neither smears into nor irritates the thin skin of the eyelid and the sensitive eyes.

Review in detail:– Unlike the many conventional liquid eyeliners, this eyeliner comes with a flexible precision tip applicator that shoulders the job of creating no-fuss defined lines or wings swiftly. It is a rich-pigmented formula with a satin-soft finish. The definition stays for 8 hours. It is an EWG verified and certified eyeliner that cleared all the strict health standards.


  • Killer, bold eyes without irritation.
  • Vegan composition.
  • Dermatologist and Ophthalmologist Tested.
  • Free from animal testing and harmful elements.
  • 100% tree-free paper carton.


  • Over-priced.
  • Not smudge-proof, smear-proof.
  • Require a steady hand for perfection.
Honest beauty liquid eyeliner review
Honest beauty liquid eyeliner review

6. Neutrogena Intense Gel Eyeliner (Best overall)

The X-factor:A liquid pen eyeliner, gentle on sensitive eyes and does not run down.

Sketch out the perfect drama on your sensitive eyes with a skin-friendly liquid formula that won’t crack or melt down into the eyes, causing discomfort. Unlike the conventional liquid, the pen edition doesn’t need a steady hand.

Review in detail:– The attributes of the best liquid eyeliner for sensitive eyes lies in its formulation and design. The rich-pigmented strokes are formulated from natural honey and coconut that won’t smudge by water or sweat. It is quick and easy to glide. The precise-tip applicator does not fray and forms a sharp, even, and clean look with one stroke.


  • Dry up in seconds.
  • Long-lasting.
  • Hypoallergenic.
  • Come in colorful shades.
  • Price in budget.


  • Do not create a smoky look.
  • Hard to get off without oils.
Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner review
Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner for sensitive eyes

7. Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner (naturally nourishing)

The X-factor:It is the natural nourishing formula for sensitive eyes.

With 99.9% sourced from nature composition: the eyeliner sits comfortably on the waterline and nourishes the skin to complement the bright, sultry, and natural look instead of irritating.

Review in detail:– The composition primarily includes jojoba oil, mango seed oil, meadow foam seed oil, and chamomile extract. It makes the eyeliner pencil hypoallergenic and nourishing for sensitive eyes. Its soft formula glides swiftly on the waterline, enhances the natural color of the eyes but never melts into the eyes. It has a cedar wood structure and comes in 3 shades.


  • Long-lasting wear.
  • Ophthalmologist-tested.
  • Free from fragrance, paraben, and other harmful elements.
  • Never tested on animals.
  • Budget-friendly.


  • May smudge a little.
  • It may break off while sharpening.
Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner for allergic skin
Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner Review

8. Almay Liquid Eyeliner (Sparkling)

The X-factor:An intense formula that works great on sensitive eyes.

In the search for the best hypoallergenic liquid eyeliner, this one is another stop for its skin-friendly formula that help create intense, sharp, sparkling, inked eyes with a swift but no irritation.

Review in detail:The powerful liquid formula has an infusion of pearl essence. This essence works to make the eyes beautifully sultry. Being made from chemical-free ingredients: it never feels heavy and uncomfortable. The precise-tip brush glides without skipping to create clean lines or wings. The ‘inkwell bottle’ delivers the proper color to every dip.


  • Hypoallergenic, fragrance-free formula.
  • Variable option of shades.
  • Ophthalmologist-tested.
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wears.
  • Cruelty-free.


  • High in price.
  • Not good staying power.
  • The brush is a bit stiff.
Almay liquid eyeliner for sensitive eyes
Almay liquid eyeliner review

9. Kiko Milano – Definition eyeliner (super-stay formula)

The X-factor:Bye-bye touch-ups; bye-bye smudgy eyes forever.

The uniqueness of this eyeliner lies in its surpassing staying power. This eyeliner stays the same even after washing the face. So, the question of smudge or transfer to wipe goes in vain when it is on your eyes.

Review in detail:– This waterproof eyeliner has a slightly creamy formula that makes it easier for every woman to glide on the waterline- no matter if she is a novice or experienced. The flexible, fine application brush fits perfectly to draw the intense black shiny texture. One stroke of it, thick or thin, increases the brightness of the eyes and makes the makeup more glamorous.


  • A High-quality, non-comedogenic formula reduces the allergy risk.
  • Stays water, smudge, and transfer-resistant for the day.
  • Clinically and ophthalmological tested.
  • Paraben-free.
  • Easy to remove.


  • High in price.
  • Take time to dry.
Kiko Milano definition eyeliner review
Kiko Milano definition eyeliner for sensitive skin

10. Fifth & Skin Better’n Ur Eyes Eyeliner Pencil

The X-factor:It is a nourishing, natural, no-tear eyeliner pencil for sensitive eyes.

Shed no more tears, and no more scratching your eyes due to irritation because this hypoallergenic eyeliner pencil heals the eyes and nourishes them. Moreover, the natural formula promotes the growth of the eyelashes.

Review in detail:– The reason the eyeliner pencil is one of the best for sensitive eyes is its 99% natural composition. It primarily has the healing agent jojoba oil and growth promoter castor oil, which facilitates the growth of the eyelashes. Though it is a pencil eyeliner, its rich-pigmented, soft, and creamy formula glides smoothly without pulling or tugging the delicate skin.


  • Accentuated, defined, and nourished eyes.
  • The water-resistant formula lasts all day.
  • Free from gluten, mineral, chemicals, and fragrance.
  • Certified cruelty-free.
  • Sharpener included.


  • High-priced.
  • Available in 2 shades.
Fifth & Skin eyeliner pencil for allergic sensitive skin
Fifth & Skin eyeliner pencil review

11. Marcelle Retractable Eyeliner (2-in-1)

The X-factor: It is an eyeliner with a spongy smudge applicator.

Sketch out the casual enhanced eyes, the trendy cat eyes, or the sultry smoky eyes with a single lining pencil because this eyeliner pencil comes with a sponge tip to create the smudgy, smoky eyes for a special occasion.

Review in detail:– The retractable eyeliner has a soft, creamy, ultra velvety crayon tip. It is a skin-friendly formula with no fragrance. It glides smoothly on the waterline without slip and skips. You get the perfect bold, beautiful look; very comforting. To create sultry, smoky eyes, smudge with the flexible sponge tip as much as you want to intensify the look.


  • Dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested.
  • A waterproof, smear-proof formulation stays for hours.
  • Suit sensitive eyes and contact lens wearer.
  • Come in colorful shades.


  • A bit high-priced.
Marcelle retractable eyeliner in US review
Marcelle retractable eyeliner for sensitive eyes review

12. EpiLynx Liquid Eyeliner by Dr. Liia (clinically formulated)

The X-factor:An all-day eyeliner for sensitive eyes resultant of personal needs and experience.

When it is about your need and previous experience- you need something pure that blends beauty with comfort and enhance it. This liquid eyeliner generates the exact result in your sensitive eyes.

Review in detail:– The liquid eyeliner comes in a pen form with a precision tip that glides precisely and smoothly on the waterline. It is a rich-pigmented formula that creates the bold and beautiful look you always wanted but with no tear, tingling, or irritation. It does not bleed, smudge, or smear. The eyeliner is stripped from additives and harmful elements.


  • Clinically formulated.
  • Vegan formula.
  • Available in colorful variants.
  • Free from toxins, chemicals, gluten, and animal testing.
  • Budget-friendly.


  • The application tip is stiff.
  • Do not get off without oil.
Epi Lynx Liquid Eyeliner for daily use
Epi Lynx Liquid Eyeliner Review

How to choose eyeliner for sensitive eyes?

Step 1: Go for natural or vegan and non-toxic composition:

Natural and vegan compositions are skin-friendly. They are free from harmful toxins, which do not irritate or tingle eyes and affect vision. They are great for the health of not only sensitive but every eye.

Step 2: Say YES to the weightless, waterproof, smudge-proof formula:

You won’t wear eyeliner again if it smudges and smear into the eyes or feel heavy. A weightless, smudge-proof formula sits perfectly on the eyes, even on sensitive eyes. And you feel comfortable while looking beautiful.

Step 3: Look for long-lasting, rich-pigmented eyeliners:

Our eyelid, the thinnest layer of skin, has all probability of losing moisture. So, while you are working on enhancing the beauty of your eyes- pick a long-lasting one, rich-pigmented eyeliner so that it won’t dry up your eyes.

FAQs about the best hypoallergenic eyeliners for sensitive eyes

Which is the best eyeliner for sensitive eyes?

Physician’s Formula enhancing eyeliner is the best eyeliner for sensitive eyes considering composition, performance, and cost. Other best are NYX Mechanical eyeliner pencil, Neutrogena Intense Gel Eyeliner, Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner, Burt’s Bee Nourishing Eyeliner, and EpiLynx Liquid Eyeliner.

Which is the best hypoallergenic liquid eyeliner for sensitive eyes?

Maybelline Liquid Pen eyeliner, Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner, and Epilynx Liquid Eyeliner are the best liquid eyeliner for sensitive eyes.

Which is the best waterproof eyeliner for sensitive eyes?

Kiko Milano Definition eyeliner is the best hypoallergenic eyeliner with super stay formula for sensitive eyes. It is a non-comedogenic formula.

Is NYX eyeliner hypoallergenic?

NYX Cosmetics products are cruelty-free and hypoallergenic. Their eyeliner collection is superb for those with sensitive eyes, especially contact users.

Which is the best naturally composed hypoallergenic eyeliner for sensitive eyes?

Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner and Fifth & Skin Better’n Ur Eyes Eyeliner Pencil are hypoallergenic eyeliner with 99% natural composition.

Which is the best hypoallergenic drugstore eyeliner?

Physician’s Formula and Epilynx are the best drugstore eyeliners because of their clinical formulation.

Which is the least irritating eyeliner?

Eyeliner with a natural or clinical formula devoid of harmful ingredients irritates the eyes the least. The 12 names here fall on the list of the least or no irritating eyeliner.

How do I remove waterproof eyeliner?

To accomplish this task, choose your allies wisely. When it comes to makeup remover, opt for an oil-based solution. To apply it, use a cotton pad. Leave on for 20 seconds before rubbing gently. Once done, take a mild soap to wash your face.

Can eyeliner blur vision?

The waxes and oils of eyeliner can adhere to contact lenses and build up if used more than once a day. The complications include irritation and redness, and sometimes blurred vision.

Is using eyeliner good for dry eyes?

Eyeliner, mascara, and related products can clog the meibomian glands in the eyelids, which produces the oil for your tears. It happens if you use glittery eye makeup or apply eyeliner to the inner portion of your lash line, leading to or worsening dry eyes.

Final words: Best waterproof eyeliner for sensitive eyes

Sensitive eyes do not mean you should not use anything; instead, they should have specialized formulas. After all, your eyes are exceptional. Aren’t they? So, get the sensitive eyeliner you find best, wear them and bring back the long-lost dramas your eyes carried once.

And yes, share the experience with your friends here and near you.

Divya Gupta
Divya Gupta

Divya Gupta is a business management and economics professional with a passion for travel and beauty. She holds a Postgraduate Diploma in Management (Tourism & Leisure) from the Indian Institute of Tourism & Travel and a Bachelor of Arts (Honors) degree in Economics from the University of Delhi.
Her business acumen paired with her enthusiasm for new destinations and cosmetics enables her to provide insightful recommendations and reviews.
In addition to her formal studies, Ms. Gupta continually educates herself and stays up-to-date on innovations in the beauty sector as well, allowing her to offer advice on cutting-edge skincare, makeup, and hairstyling techniques.

Articles: 85